In 1974, architect Louis I. Kahn died in Penn Station of a heart attack.
The obituaries said he was survived by a wife and daughter, but soon,
everybody would discover that he had two other families. Nathaniel Kahn
(My Father's Garden) was his only son, and a member of one of those
'hidden' families. All his life he wondered about his father, and the
strange dichotomy between the world-famous and influential architect,
and the man who fathered children between three different women. Nathaniel
grew up with a huge empty space in his life, and many questions for his
father Louis, who died when he was eleven. My Architect is Nathaniel's
way of trying to discover more about his father, by interviewing Louis'
relatives and friends, and learning more about the buildings he made.
Perhaps, he thinks, he will reach some sort of emotional closure.
The result is an uneven documentary. The film is not about Louis
Kahn, but about Nathaniel Kahn's search for his father, and although the
intentions are altruistic, there is sometimes a self-serving air about
the film. Remember, the title of the documentary is "My"
Architect. What exactly is the point of watching Nathaniel rollerblade
across the Salk Institute? Or watching him try to (unsuccessfully) put
on a yarmulke? Nathaniel is not a great interviewer, and sometimes allows
his subjects to ramble. The worst aspect of his interviewing, and of the
editing, is his tendency to allow long awkward silences. Sometimes they
are artificial, as one can see the subjects talking in the background,
but there is no noise.
The subject matter makes up for Nathaniel's deficiencies as a director.
Louis Kahn became famous near the end of his life, and brought back a
sense of majesty and timelessness to his work. He liked working with simple
geometric shapes, and many of his buildings were purposefully reminiscent
of ancient castles. My Architect visits many of his works, from
the previously mentioned Salk Institute in San Diego, to the Yale Art
Gallery, the Richards Medical Towers, and the stunning Exeter Library
and the Capital Complex in Dhaka, Bangladesh. There is something spiritual
about Kahn's works, and to his credit, Nathaniel does do justice to his
father's work. Nathaniel arranges the documentary not chronologically,
but topically, and seems to bounce around without much focus until about
the midway point, when everything betweens to tighten.
Then, My Architect takes a more personal turn. Through various
interviews (including brief ones with I.M. Pei and Frankd Gehry), Nathaniel
tries to discover Louis Kahn the man, as opposed to Louis Kahn the architect.
He married Esther and bore Sue Ann. Later, he had an affair with Anne
Tyng, a coworker, and bore Alexandra. Even later, he had an affair with
Nathaniel's mother, Harriet Pattison. In actuality, Louis was married
to his work. Still, he managed to find time for all three families. The
most emotional interviews are the ones with Tyng, Pattison, and a reunion
of the Kahn children. Here, one can see the frustration and anger that
his family felt at Louis, yet there is also a deep love. Kahn was described
as a brilliant and charismatic man, and this was undoubtedly one of the
reasons that Pattison and Tyng were able to live through this strange
contradiction. As Nathaniel mentions, these women were single mothers
at a time when being a single mother was a scandal. At the end of My
Architect, it seems like Nathaniel has achieved some sense of closure,
and, despite the sometimes amateurish feel of the film, the viewer has
a clearer, yet not full picture of Louis Kahn.
|