Joan loves her husband more than anything else in the world. Her love
for him is so strong that she calls it a madness of sort, a near obsession
with him. Joan (Pilar Lopez de Ayala, Kisses for Everyone, Bailame
el Agua) also happens to be a Princess, the daughter of King Ferdinand
and Queen Isabella of Spain (of Columbus fame). Mad Love is Joan's
story, told in the revisionist style that always seems to change these
women from Europe of long ago to modern-thinking, headstrong women. Sometimes
it works, and sometimes it doesn't. For writer/director Vicente Aranda
(Jealousy, The Naked Eye), this means tweaking history just
enough to turn Mad Love into something more superficial. It's like
the film version of those romance novels with the 'clench' covers that
abound in bookstores.
The story begins near the end of the fifteenth century. Isabella decides
to marry Joan of Castile to Philip the Handsome (Daniele Liotti, Days
of Grace) to form a political alliance with the Hapsburgs. This is
a marriage of convenience, not one of love. Yet the two manage to fall
in love with each other. At this point, Joan is fourth in line for the
throne of Castile. In the next couple of years, through a series of tragic
deaths, she begins Queen of Castile. She and Philip move back to Spain
to begin their reign in 1504. Later, she would be declared mad, and locked
away in the castle for the rest of her life. The events leading up to
this declaration is probably where Aranda 'retells' history the most.
There is a reason Philip is called "the Handsome," not unlikely
because of his chiseled body, smoldering eyes, and flowing tresses. Liotti
looks like he stepped off the cover of a romance novel. The attraction
between Joan and Philip is immediate, and they enjoy showing their affection
for each other loudly and often. However, Philip is merely eye candy,
having nothing much else going on upstairs. He is not satisfied with just
Joan, and cheats on her behind her back. This drives Joan insane. How
can he wander when she is willing to give him more love than is humanly
possible? Instead of hating him, she wants to do what she can to win his
love back. In a way, it is her delusion that Philip will return to her.
Aranda never gives any attention to why the people around Joan think
she is mad. The way that he presents it, she was grossly misunderstood.
This makes her look normal and everybody else look kooky, and that doesn't
make that much sense, and is probably the main weakness of the story.
Okay, she is outspoken, wants to breastfeed her baby, and has a temper,
but that isn't too far out of the ordinary. The court and people around
her make it seem like a cardinal sin. On the other hand, her extreme focus
on winning back Philip does cause her to act erratically towards some
of the nobles, causing them to think she is crazy. Mad Love shifts
moods in the end towards politics, and some of the behind-the-scenes power
grabs for the throne, Aranda is never able to get audiences to believe
this given his penchant for bodice-ripping action in the beginning. But
what he does do is give Lopez de Ayala a great role, where she successfully
shifts among a wide range of emotions, and also must handle Joan changing
from an innocent princess to a regal queen.
|